This thread show how you should rate an animation. Here it is:
Flash Master (10)
High Expert (9)
Medium Expert (8 )
Low Expert (7)
High Intermediate (6)
Medium Intermediate (5)
Low Intermediate (4)
High Beginner (3)
Medium Beginner (2)
Low Beginner (1)
Horrid Animator (0)
James Moer (-10,000,000,000)
Okay, so stick to those when rating an animation!